Monday, 1 July 2013

The selfish hobby

Not much progress on 'Belstone' in the last month due to other commitments - work, family, voluntary organisations, that kind of stuff.  I managed to grab a couple of hours to sort out the wiring, which now uses heavy copper bus bars running the full length of the board, and a neat self-latching relay to switch the frogs on the diamond crossing - see the N Gauge Forum for full details on how I got this one to work.



Yesterday afternoon, after I had cut the grass, trimmed the hedge and pulled up about two thousand stinging nettles, I got out the modelling stuff and started constructing the largest single building on 'Belstone' - the combined station building and stationmaster's house, based on the very typical North British structure at Scotsgap Junction.  And I realised one of the reasons why I enjoy railway modelling so much.  It is the only thing in my life for which I am answerable to no-one else.  Not my customers (I run a car repair business), my wife (lovely though she is), the Government, or anyone else.  The only person I have to please is myself.  There is no pressure of any kind.  If it takes me the next ten years to construct this one building, it doesn't matter at all.  It is, in that sense, a very selfish hobby, but not in a bad way.

The station building is still at an early stage although already looking recognisably North British, so no photos yet.  Construction is the usual Plastikard, and very fiddly to put together, being quite a complicated little structure.

In other news, I finally joined the N Gauge Society, and as a result have a set of B&B magnetic couplers in the post to me as I write this.  If I can get them to work I can put in the electromagnets for the uncouplers, turn the baseboard the right way up again and start thinking about scenic construction.  That's after I have built a supporting frame for the baseboard and rebuilt the fiddle yard from my previous layout to suit the new one.

Monday, 27 May 2013

Relics

I took another trip up to the barn where I store all the junk I can't bear to throw away.  The main purpose was to dig out my box of enamel paints in the hope that they hadn't all dried out in storage (they hadn't, even though some of them must be thirty years old by now).  On the way out I bumped into a box which I had ignored because I thought it contained yet more of my late mother's gardening books.  The box moved in an un-booklike way, so I opened it and found a large quantity of model railway items that  I had either forgotten owning, assumed lost or thought I had flogged on eBay years ago.

The haul included various building kits and materials, four BachFarish maroon Mk1s, two Minitrix Gresley coaches, two locomotives, my old H&M Clipper (bought second hand in about 1978) and a little hand-held Gaugemaster controller.  So I set about trying to bring some of my old DCC-resistant locos to life, thinking that if I could get them to run I might be able to sell them.

First up was a Class 29 diesel, built many years ago using a Langley whitemetal body kit on an American Atlas chassis, and probably the only loco kit I ever actually finished.  I wired up the old Clipper, applied power to the track and the '29' ran after a fashion - jerky and hesitant, but it had never been a great runner so I wasn't expecting much.

Next for testing was an Ivatt 2MT 2-6-0.  An old Minitrix model, bought cheap as a rather battered non-runner and remotored with a Mashima can motor, back in the days when I still had steady hands and good eyesight and hadn't yet discovered High Commissioner whisky (available at all good petrol stations).  I put that one on the track and it just buzzed at me.  Ho hum.  I took the body off, found the motor had seized through lack of use, freed it off and applied a few spots of oil to the gears and bearings.

I then decided to try the little Gaugemaster controller.  The 2MT moved: I galloped it up and down the track a few times, then tried a bit of slow speed running.  Good as gold: no stalling or hesitation over the points, controllable down to a slow crawl, a slight wobble in reverse but then it always used to do that (probably a slightly distorted traction tyre).

I tried the class 29 again with the Gaugemaster.  Noisy, but good.  I don't remember it running that well ten years ago.  Metro-Cammell DMU (Farish body, Kato chassis) lurched forward a few inches and stopped.  Strip, oil, reassemble and I now had three exceptionally good slow runners.  By now I was on a roll, so I thought I would tackle the Class 26 (TPM resin body, Farish chassis, Hanazono 5-pole motor, split gears on two axles).  I dropped in the new wheelsets that I had bought and never fitted, dab of oil in the appropriate areas, and... same again.  No stalling, no hesitation, slow speed control as good as anything you might get in the larger scales.

So after an hour or so happily 'playing trains' I realised I have a problem.  The only reason I decided to go down the DCC route was in the hope of achieving the reliable slow running that had always eluded me in 'N'.   I don't need directional lighting, sound, or the ability to run two locos on the same section of track. Yet here I am with four old relics from the bad old days and a controller I found in a box, getting exactly the kind of dependable, consistent operation I wanted, without a single chip in sight.  Am I barking up the wrong tree?

Maybe not.  Two problems with the Gaugemaster.  Firstly, a whole lot of motor noise from all four locos.  Secondly, the motors are getting very hot even after a fairly short period of slow running.  Whatever waveform that little controller is putting out it is a long way from pure DC, and Japanese motors don't like it. I didn't have that problem with the J39 on the Dynamis Pro controller, and that has a Japanese can motor as well.

We need some trials.  Of the relics, the easiest to convert to DCC is the Class 26.  So I will fit a chip to it and see how it compares with 12V DC control, and report back.


Belstone goes all West Highland on me, circa 1967.  Class 29 pauses between shunting operations as a Class 26, newly outshopped in rail blue, runs into the station with a passenger train


Normal Working Resumed.  Ivatt 2MT heads an absolutely typical Border Country branch line train.


Sunday, 26 May 2013

A sense of place

Sunday afternoon, and having mowed the lawn and pulled up a few random nettles to keep my landlord happy I settled down to some more useful activity.  First job was to make the trackplan alterations mentioned previously - lift and relay the bay platform and loco servicing roads, and slew the goods siding towards the centre of the baseboard to make more room for a goods platform.  All nice and easy.  I haven't reinstated the wiring yet as I am still minded to redo the whole lot while I have the chance.  It will be a lot more difficult once I start putting scenery in place.

Having done which I thought I would have a crack at constructing the first of Belstone's (very few) buildings. If you are looking to recreate the look and feel of a particular area, buildings are important.  Every pre-grouping railway company had its own distinct architectural style.  A good model railway should allow you to take an educated guess at the region it represents, without a single locomotive or item of rolling stock being visible.  And of all the various railway-related structures, probably the most distinctive are signalboxes.

Granted, some companies used off-the-shelf products by companies like Saxby & Farmer or The Railway Signal Company.  But most of them used boxes to their own design, and there was a lot of variety.  One of the best-known was the wooden framed box designed by the Midland Railway.  An early example of modular construction, it could be adapted to suit anything from a small branch line to a major junction simply by increasing the number of window bays.  The design was immortalised thanks to Airfix, who produced a kit in the 1960s for a typical mid-sized Midland box (actually based on Oakham) which must have sold in hundreds of thousands.

Likewise the North British had its own way of doing things. Their boxes were square, solid things with fewer windows than most other companies, and instantly recognisable.  So there was no way I was going to get away with a 'generic' plastic kit-built signalbox for Belstone.  I dug around in the scrapbox, found a pile of Plastikard sheets of various kinds (including embossed stone, slate and brick) and set to work with a Swann-Morton scalpel and some glue, as well as the Ian Futers drawings for Scotsgap signalbox.

After about four hours and a slightly burnt dinner, I now have something which is far from finished, has a lot of rough edges to tidy up, but is still unmistakeably a North British signalbox.  Here it is with one of my unfinished projects from years ago, a resin bodied Class 26 diesel on a Farish chassis, now rendered completely pointless by the Dapol model and so unlikely ever to be completed.


And here is an overall view of the layout showing the realignment work, as compared with version 1.0:



I am still not completely happy with the track plan.  In real life I don't think the loco servicing road would have been accessed via a headshunt off the bay platform.  More likely, given the available space it would have been through a facing crossover interlaced with the access points to the bay platform.  Oddly, Peco have not so far included this particular track formation in their Code 55 range.  But I think the revised arrangement looks better and more railway-like than the original, so I will try to leave it alone now.

Coming next - having managed to build most of a signalbox I will tackle the station buildings (same constructional techniques, just bigger).  I also need to decide whether to build the road overbridge from scratch or just use the Peco one.  Road bridges are a lot less distinctive than signalboxes, and if there is anything unusual or special about North British bridges I cannot see it.

Thursday, 23 May 2013

The invisible turntable

No sooner had I finished that last blog post than I had a thought.  Turntables.  Scotsgap had one, so did Rothbury, Reedsmouth, Alston, and just about everywhere else in Northumberland where trains terminated.  Belstone would have had a turntable, only a little one to be sure, but it would have had one.  But where?

Perhaps Scotsgap again provides the answer.  The turntable and inspection pit were on the other side of the road bridge from the station and water tower.  In model railway terms, in the fiddle yard.  So instead of shortening the loco servicing road I need to lengthen it, to go under the road bridge and into the fiddle yard the other side (where, as it happens, there actually is a turntable, to reduce the need for handling small delicate locomotives).

The main problem with this is that I have deliberately spaced the servicing road well away from the running line, which means I will have to lift and relay the access pointwork and the bay platform road. Meh. That will teach me to make cocky blog posts about layout planning.  Lucky I haven't started ballasting yet....

A none too flat field

A long time ago I bought a book entitled 'Landscape Modelling' by Barry Norman.  Not the film critic and pickled onion seller, the other Barry Norman who built a rather fabulous layout called 'Petherick'.  Here's a photo of it that I found on the Web:

Petherick

My copy of his book is probably still in the storage shed, I'll have to dig it out.  But one of the points he made is that to be convincing, a model railway should be set in a landscape, not just plonked down on a flat board with a few pimply hills added as an afterthought.  Now I only have a space 4' x 1' to play with, which limits just how much Northumbrian countryside I can include, but I still want what little scenery there is to be convincing.

Another issue raised by Barry Norman, Iain Rice and others was the concept of managing sightlines.  The idea is to arrange scenery, buildings etc in such a way as to draw the viewer's attention to the middle of the baseboard and away from the edges, where the little world you are trying to create comes to an abrupt halt. So with these principles in mind I set about 'Belstone' with a marker pen and the May 2013 issue of Railway Modeller, which contains a set of 2mm scale drawings for the absolutely typical North British station building and other structures at Scotsgap Junction.  The end result being this:


The basic assumption is that Belstone station would have been built on a field on the edge of the town, gently sloping from the 'country' to platform end and from the back of the station to the front.  There aren't many flat fields in northern Northumberland, and most of those are next to rivers and prone to flooding.  So the North British would have had to make the best of what was available, and use gangs of navvies to clear a level space where the station and track would be.

The station is approached through a shallow cutting: the line then passes under a minor road bridge at the station entrance.  I will build this on a slight skew, which will naturally draw the viewer's attention towards the water tower and away from the back corner.  An access road then gently descends on an embankment to level out at the back of the station building at around platform level, with a sloping bank behind it rising up to meet the backscene.

The platform end is trickier as there are no structures in the foreground apart from a cattle dock. The best I can think is to have another slight bank along the end, and plant some trees along it.  Just one problem: I don't have enough space.  So I intend to cheat and extend the baseboard by an inch and a half along the back and across the platform end.  I will also have to make a couple of minor alterations to the track plan: shorten the loco servicing road by a couple of inches to make room for the embankment, and slew the goods siding across to allow a bit more space for a loading platform.

Buildings are easy (apart from the minor point that I have never scratch-built a building before).  Thanks to Ian Futers, pretty much everything will be Scotsgap.  station building (built as a mirror image to put the stationmaster's house at the buffer stop end, otherwise it will not have a garden), signalbox (at the end of the platform ramp as per Scotsgap, but narrowed slightly to fit between the main and bay platform roads), and water tower / coaling stage (again mirrored to put the water hose at the station end, so it will reach locos which arrive at Belstone tender-first).  Scotsgap also had an open inspection pit for oiling motion and other minor maintenance, but I am not sure this would have been positioned quite so close to the water tower.  If the driver was under the loco while the fireman filled the tender, and the fireman didn't shut off the water in time, the driver would get an early bath...

There will also be some coal staithes, cattle dock (I can't find any photos showing what if any fencing a North British cattle dock would have had) a weighbridge and hut (tucked in near the diamond crossing) and possibly a platelayer's hut somewhere.  I thought about putting an engine shed on the loco servicing road (Rothbury had one), but I reckon it would make this corner look a bit too crowded.  Come to think of it, Rothbury also had a turntable, and I definitely don't have space for that.

I plan to build the water tower first as this will give me time to experiment with constructional techniques before I get stuck into the bigger buildings.  I will probably build all the structures (including platforms) before I start any landscaping, so that I can arrange the landscape contours to meet them, rather than having to cut holes afterwards.  This is the first layout I have ever really put any thought into before building it, and I have to say I find it a very satisfying way of doing things.  Once you have made the big decisions (who built the railway, where and why) everything else flows naturally from that.  Previously I have started with something along the lines of 'I want a double track station with a goods yard, loco shed and branch platform' and then tried to bend the 'back story' into shape to fit the model.  If there is really a difference between a train set and a model railway (and most non-modellers would say there isn't) then it is probably right there.

Wednesday, 22 May 2013

Grandad's wire

My grandfather spent most of his working life underground at Ollerton Colliery in Nottinghamshire.  One of the lesser known perks of the job was offcuts of detonator wire:  single core PVC coated wire in various colours.  He used to bring back carrier bags full of the stuff, and every layout that my father and I built in the 1970s and 1980s was wired with it.  He died in 1982, just a couple of years after retiring.  He was a lovely man, tall and solidly built with hands like shovels, and never an unkind word to say about anyone.  When I was eight or nine years old we used to go out by 'bus to Tuxford or Retford, and he would sit down and puff away at his pipe as we watched a succession of East Coast expresses thunder past. He was not a railway enthusiast but he encouraged my interest and always bought me a new model locomotive for Christmas. Alfred Silvester, 'Grampy', this blog post is dedicated to you.

Anyway, while I was hunting about for various electrical bits and pieces to wire up 'Belstone', I came across a tangled bundle of yellow wire.  Grandad's wire, the very last bit.  I cut it into three inch lengths, drilled lots of holes in the trackbed and soldered it to the rails in all the appropriate places.  Then it was just a question of turning the baseboard over and joining up all these wire 'droppers'.  I was going to give a blow by blow account of how I got the layout wired up and running, but that would probably lose me the few readers I have.  Layout wiring bores me, and will probably bore you too.

Also, even though the wiring is now in place and everything works, I'm not happy with it.  Messy, vulnerable to damage and difficult to trace faults.  I used a load of bits of wire salvaged from my last layout, which made it difficult to use any kind of colour coding, and the wire itself was rubbish (unlike Grandad's wire).  So at some point I will probably redo it, this time using thick copper wire busbars running the full length of the board - track positive and negative, and common returns for point motors and uncouplers.


Belstone rolls over to have its tummy tickled.  See what I mean about messy?


Most of the wiring was straightforward, following the basic rule for live frog points - always feed power to the toe of the point, never the heel.  DCC purists will argue that my wiring is all wrong, since most of the track sections are only 'live' if the points controlling them are set correctly.  But the ability to derail locos by running them against incorrectly set points is a feature of DCC that I can probably live without, and as I will not be having lights or sound in any of my locos I don't need them to be constantly receiving a DCC signal anyway.

The only really tricky bit was the live frog diamond crossing.  The instructions recommend using a DPDT toggle switch to feed power to the frogs, but I wanted to see if frog switching could be done automatically, and anyway it was late on Monday evening and I didn't have a DPDT toggle switch.  So I hit upon the idea of treating the diamond as two 'virtual points' back to back, and switching the frogs using a couple of SEEP point motors with built-in SPDT switches, the same motors that I used for the rest of the pointwork. Very Heath Robinson, but my 'Frankenstein switch' works just fine.  The motors are electrically linked to the point motor for one of the siding approach roads.  I have since looked into doing the same thing more neatly with relays, and found a double-coil DPDT self-latching relay that should do the same job.


The Frankenstein Switch - two point motors bolted together back to back

The big question - does it run?  Oh yes. Beautifully.  I did about an hour of testing with the J39, played about with the various CV settings on the DCC system, and I now have the kind of reliable slow running that I have never achieved before in 'N' gauge.  This is a great relief:  Belstone is, as I have said, all about shunting, which means reliable slow speed operation is critical.  I am now a True DCC Believer, but will try to avoid boring others on the subject.

What next?  I only have one loco, coupling issues mean I can't yet operate trains anyway, and the fiddle yard is still in storage forty mile away.  So my next post will be about scenery. Probably.

Monday, 20 May 2013

Send in the navvies

Having spent ages messing about with points, point motors, uncouplers etc it is finally time to move on to the fun bit.  So yesterday morning, after a hearty breakfast, the V.I. Lenin Red Flag Workers Progressive Shock Construction Brigade swung into action with the aim of going from bare baseboard to running layout in a single day.

First step was to work out where the holes for the point motors and uncouplers needed to be.  I assembled the point formations 'dry', carefully aligned everything on the baseboard, marked out the point positions with a pencil, then stuck headless pins through the actuating holes in the tiebars to provide a marker.  I also marked the position for the electromagnets. Having lifted the track again I drilled holes in all the appropriate places, gave the baseboard a final light sanding and got the glue out.

My intention was to use PVA glue alone, with heavy weights and drawing pins to hold the track down until the glue dried.  However, having laid the point formation at the station throat, I realised I had got one of the points in the wrong place, and at this point I found that unsticking glued-down track is all too easy, at least with the glue I was using.  So I started again, this time using a mixture of PVA glue and track pins.  Once the track is ballasted I should be able to remove the pins which are a bit obtrusive to my eyes.

Tracklaying progressed reasonably smoothly, apart from the diamond crossing which needed two short sections of track to be cut to a very precise length.  Needless to say I screwed this up and had to have a second go at it.  Measure once, cut twice... By lunchtime I had all the track laid.  Incidentally, when using Code 55 track you need to fit dummy sleepers at the joins.  I found the easiest way to do this was to use a spot of Superglue to attach them to the underside of the fishplates before positioning the track sections.  I also found that Peco insulated fishplates are too thick for the dummy sleepers to fit underneath them, so I will have to cut up some sleepers and glue them between the rails to fill the gaps where I have used insulated fishplates.

Next stage was to fit my modified point motors.  A couple of them needed the baseboard holes opening out slightly (measure once, cut twice) and I ran into serious trouble at the station throat where there are two points next to each other.  It hadn't occurred to me that by putting the operating pin in the centre of the tiebar I would not have space to fit motors to both points.  I lashed up an extension using a Peco remote point motor base, a bit of steel wire, a brass tube and some Araldite, and that was that problem solved.

By now it was teatime, and after several fortifying vodkas the Shock Construction Brigade started on point motor wiring.  At some point I will need to build a control panel but for now I needed something simpler.  The answer was to attached a screw terminal block (or 'choccy block' as they are generally known) to the outside edge of the baseboard, run all the point motor wires to it and then use a probe poked into the terminal block to operate the points.  I wired the crossover points at the terminus end as a pair, also the points controlling the bay platform and engine shed road.  My box of bits yielded a Gaugemaster capacitor discharge unit, I connected up an old Triang controller to provide the power, and all but one of the points worked.  The rogue motor was binding on the hole in the baseboard even though I had already had a go at fettling it (measure once, cut three times) and with this problem sorted I now had fully working points.

6.30pm, and after taking the dogs for their evening walk I set about the really tedious job of soldering wire droppers to the rail sections ready to connect everything up. I needed to put in about forty of these, and the task was not made easier by using solder that was much too large in diameter.  Also my eyes were starting to get tired.  So in the end I didn't get any trains running.  I connected up the first few droppers, tested the track with the multimeter, found I had somehow created a short circuit across the rails, and gave up.  Wiring can wait until the next session.  

A few pictures:


Overall view, station throat is on the left.  Clive the greyhound is unimpressed.


The classic branch line terminus - run round loop, bay platform with access to engine shed, coal siding near right, general goods far right and cattle dock at the far end.  The only unusual feature is the short diamond crossing, allowing two decent length goods sidings in a small space.  I can't remember where I saw that, but I like it.


Metro-Cammell DMU waits where the platform would be, if there was one.  This is a refugee from a previous layout - a very old Farish product with the hopeless motor bogie replaced with a Kato chassis. A bit out of period for Belstone, but it gives some idea of the overall scale of the layout.